My Cheating Heart

When I returned from my business trip to Denver, things weren’t as they were before I left. N was slightly distant. His behavior was different. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it, but something was definitely off.

Over the course of our time together, I noticed certain behaviors of his that raised red flags. For instance, he spent a lot of time at the gym. Now, I’ve known gym rats in my time, but I’ve never known anyone who spent quite as much time there as him. Or, at least that’s where he told me he was. Night after night, he’d spend 3+ hours lifting and doing cardio. Normally, I would appreciate such dedication, but after some of the stories he told me about what went down at the downtown Hoboken New York Sports Club, I started to get worried he might be participating (including stories of guys blowing each other in the steam room). I had no evidence or proof he was doing anything wrong, but deep down I had a suspicious feeling everything wasn’t on the level.

I really came to resent that gym. We both belonged to NYSC. I would work out in the uptown Hoboken NYSC which is newer and above ground, and I would ask him to join me. He always declined, telling me he was going downtown. I came to realize why we went downtown so much. He was getting his ego stroked, which was really getting to me. In the beginning I thought it was cute. I would call him things like princess and make noises as if I were blowing up a balloon when his head got too big. But, things started getting out of hand. He would come home from the gym bragging about the guys that checked him out. He would tell me about men slipping notes into his locker. Why he felt the need to share this information is beyond me. I belonged to the same family of gyms, and this NEVER happened to me. We are both attractive men. The difference was he was inviting it. I wasn’t jealous either. I had him. I didn’t need anyone else. I knew something had to be invited in some way from him for this to happen. Finally, I made blatant comments to him about why he went down there. It never fazed him. But if I said he goes there because he liked his ego stroked publicly, he got annoyed with me.

As I was beginning to wake up from the dream I thought was a relationship, I also noticed N spent a lot of time on Grindr. I know that’s how we met, and I have respect for the application, but it’s a death trap. It gets addicting and puts you in the constant mindset of being able to look constantly for something else, even if you’re already happy with what you have. It distances you from the process. If you were seeing a guy for a month and a half, and were walking down the street with him, you wouldn’t give another man the up-down in person. However, if you’re sitting next to the man you’ve been seeing, it’s possible to be looking at other men right in front of you without feeling guilty, which is what he was doing. He answered messages with me standing two feet away. This was a bold and brazen move I did not appreciate at all, even if he was just making friends.I was legitimately worried N was constantly seeking an upgrade model. I too was guilty. I was still talking to guys on Grindr and saying inappropriate things, but I never asked for a number or tried to meet up with any guys. It was more of an entertainment to pass the time.

These, among many other behaviors, created vast doubt in my mind of N’s faithfulness. He was new to the gay world. He didn’t know what he wanted. He just ended a long term relationship shortly before he met me. I was willing to be understanding of a lot of things since he was so new, and I was in his position one year prior. But, at this point, we’d been seeing each other for over a month and a half. For the sake of my emotional well-being, as well as my physical well-being, I couldn’t tolerate infidelity.

I started to get angry and resentful. When a guy from Hoboken started pursuing me on Grindr, I got sucked in. I immediately told him I was involved in a relationship and was purely looking for friends to hang out with. I had no one in my arsenal of gay friends other than Boston and NC. The conversation started off innocent, but then quickly escalated to a sexual nature. I was doing exactly what I accused N of in my mind. But, at this point, I was in revenge mode. I didn’t have proof he was cheating on me, but I knew it in my gut he was. Some of his stories didn’t hold up, and I caught him in lies. When there are inconsistencies, the mind will fill in the blanks and it has a tendency to run wild with possibilities. I also my actions because we never agreed we were exclusive. If he could philander, so could I. So when this guy asked if we could meet at my apartment for a quicky after work, I obliged.

I raced home that day and showered. Shortly after, he knocked on my door and came in. We went into my bedroom and chatted before making out. Then things got hot and heavy. It was quick but satisfying. This guy knew I was in a relationship with a guy across the street, and I told him to be discreet. So basically, I was using him for his body, and that’s it. This was a one-time gig to level the emotional playing field with N in my mind.

This isn’t who I am. I dated Broadway for ten months without cheating on him once. The thought never crossed my mind. And, he was my first gay relationship, just as I was N’s. I hated N for making me feel this way. It’s what drove me to “cheat” in the first place. But he didn’t make me do it. I did it of my own accord. Now, I know technically I didn’t do anything wrong, as we were never exclusive, but I broke my own moral code. I let myself down. I have to take responsibility for that. I did that and no one else. I didn’t like who I was becoming. And, I’m sorry and I was wrong!

That night, N was busy and didn’t spend the night. A big part of me wondered whose bed he slept in that night, but who am I to talk? I was happy, because while I wanted to seek revenge for N’s suspected cheating, I couldn’t fathom him sleeping on the same sheets I had sex with another man on. However, that night I slept on clean sheets in my bed sharing only with my guilt and my regret.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  1. #1 by Peter on October 27, 2013 - 10:44 PM

    I know that post has been there for a while but I wanted to share my feeling as well. I am a gay man (33) living with a man (54). I am right now in the same position. I left my hometown (France) for a man I met in Paris and he brought me back with him to America after a year. He had promised me the world as well which he did give. I have money to go out when I want to. I am working too so it makes it easier. Everything is his… I have nothing under my name, he takes care of our finance. I have no idea what is going on at all, I have asked to see the activities on the accounts but he does not want me to put my nose in that (weird). We are raising 2 beautiful kids, twins (7 YO). We have been together for 8 years and got married 2 years ago. I used to work in the food industry for 4 years in a catering business, my schedule was awful, I was never home during the day and evening. We were bumping to each other all the time. Then I quit my job, and worked as a freelancer for a while. I noticed some changes in his behavior… Always on his computer upstairs while I was downstairs or on his phone. I had some hints that he might be cheating on me but I did not pay attention much ( I should have)Then the sex was not that great as it used to. Out of the sudden, we stopped having sex for awhile. Months later, a friend of mine called me saying that he saw my husband entering in a hotel. I confronted him about it and he told me that he went there to pay a room to friend who could not pay his rent. I did not buy that story. It was clear that he went there to have sex with someone else. After his work he usually goes for a drink or 2 to a bar near by. I am sure he met someone there, exchanged personal phone numbers and finally meet after few text messages that I caught when i could. All his social network (FB and Skype) are full of young men (youngest than me for sure). I know that he goes on sex website and meet other guys as well. On those website he does stuff that are disgusting. Nothing has been the same since. I have so much invested in that relationship that I am giving up. I do not feel anything except pain, rage. Personally, that situation makes me hating the gay community as a whole. I cannot stand those drama queens… I feel trap because of the kids, I do love them as they were mine… They are so precious to me… I simply cannot leave them. I think the only proper action is to sacrifice myself and stay in that (Marriage, which I do not call marriage at all) and make sure they do get all the love, they need. I do not want to fail them. I must stay strong. If someone out there read that please reply to me. I would appreciate it. Kindest regard,

    • #2 by One Gay at a Time on November 3, 2013 - 6:29 PM

      Hey there. Thanks for commenting! You really put yourself and your story out there, and I give you a lot of credit for doing that.

      I sincerely hope someone else out there has better advice for you than I do, but I don’t know if I could do it. I don’t think I could stay in a relationship with someone I didn’t love. Life’s too short to go through the motions.

      It sounds like you’re stuck in a sticky situation. I think you need to take the time to find out what’s really going on. I think you should consult a lawyer and find out what your options are. Just because you leave him doesn’t mean you’d lose the children. There may be legal stopgaps to prevent this, but this is well out of my field of expertise.

      I think you should talk with friends and find out what your options really are. My heart breaks thinking about you staying in this toxic relationship, but I understand why you would put yourself through that. It speaks volumes about your character and the bounty of love you have to give. This guy doesn’t deserve one more drop of it.

      My advice is to move on, but make sure you set up a full-proof plan beforehand. I wish you the best of luck in this terrible situation! Please keep me posted and let me and the readers of this know if there is any way we can help.

      Feel free to reach out to me at

      Thanks again for sharing and good luck!!

  1. Boston in the House « One Gay at a Time
  2. 2 Can Play That Game « One Gay at a Time
  3. Darkness Falls « One Gay at a Time
  4. I Think We Need to Talk « One Gay at a Time
  5. Déjà vu « One Gay at a Time
  6. Unhappy Ending « One Gay at a Time
  7. Saturday Bar Crawl With a New Friend « One Gay at a Time
  8. My Adult Book Report « One Gay at a Time
  9. Revisiting the Past « One Gay at a Time
  10. Flip the Crazy Switch « One Gay at a Time
  11. A Night Off « One Gay at a Time
  12. High Anxiety « One Gay at a Time

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: